Hana Report on the Death of Sogand Sayadi a 15-Year-Old Girl in Kermanshah

The Hana Human Rights Organization has received information about the suspicious death of Sogand Sayadi, a 15-year-old schoolgirl from Alirezavandi village in Gilan-e Gharb County who lived in Kermanshah. According to this information, Sogand died after being severely beaten by her father. The evidence and accounts received raise the possibility of an honor-motivated killing, and also call into question how school officials responded to the threat to this child’s life.

According to information received by Hana, the administration of Rezvan School summoned Sogand’s father, Keyumars Sayyadi, to the school after learning of a matter relating to her private life. Hana’s sources say that her father severely beat her in front of her classmates and, outside the school, struck her head against a wall several times. Before leaving the school, Sogand had warned officials that her father would kill her if she went home. According to the account received, however, school officials took no effective step to protect her life and allowed her to go home with her father.

Hana’s sources also report that the beating continued at the family home, and allege that her father threw Sogand from the third floor of the building. Her lifeless body was found in the courtyard of the house the next morning. Although this information raises grave allegations against Sougand’s father, the precise cause and circumstances of her death have not yet been independently confirmed. The Kermanshah Department of Education has announced that it has begun an administrative review of the case.

From a legal standpoint, if Sogand’s warnings are confirmed and school officials were aware of the danger, their failure to intervene and report the matter could constitute a breach of the duties set out in Articles 6 and 17 of the Law on the Protection of Children and Adolescents. In Hana’s view, the case also exposes the structural failure of the Islamic Republic’s ideological, jurisprudence-based education system to protect children: a system in which the authority of the family and moral and disciplinary considerations can, in practice, take precedence over a child’s dignity, safety, and best interests. A school that should be a student’s refuge from violence, if the accounts are accurate, became one of the links in a chain that exposed her to the risk of death.

The incident must also be examined in the context of honor-based violence against girls and women in Iran, which is bound up with the control of their private lives and the justification of male family members’ authority. Article 301 of the Islamic Penal Code, by exempting a father and paternal grandfather from retaliation (qisas) for the murder of a child, also undermines equal criminal-law protection of children’s right to life. Nevertheless, the motive of honor and the criminal liability of the father in this case must be established through independent investigation.

The Hana Human Rights Organization calls for an immediate, independent, and transparent investigation into the allegations against Sogand Sayadi’s father, the determination of the cause of her death, and an examination of the possible responsibility of the school principal and other school officials. Hana stresses that no justification based on honor, family reputation, or paternal authority can license violence against children or the taking of life, and that the indifference of responsible institutions to threats against children’s lives must not go unanswered.

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular